Nick Anthony

Congratulations to nostr:nprofile1qyx8wumn8ghj7cnjvghxjmcpz4mhxue69uhk2er9dchxummnw3ezumrpdejqqgqux8xd5fcfl3k0tkc2pvy8xcf7y4jxcj55gauald0g6m9me5hwrs2xw9y4, nostr:nprofile1qqszvwvcmwhas4rvwrwgj8gqddg3kmr5nn9tf6gta7xl6glvu6aeq4qde3re3, nostr:nprofile1qyg8wumn8ghj7nn0wd68ytnhd9hx2qg4waehxw309ajkgetw9ehx7um5wghxcctwvsqzpsnz9jgkmxusuy9grv46v7cehh7966lzdsjh2mglnyxn0pwwzdsmyyrj62, nostr:nprofile1qythwumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytnxd46zuamf0ghxy6t6qy28wumn8ghj7mn0wd68ytn00p68ytnyv4mqqgzccaq65ccv9k3454480sws2wqepz73q5z0m5kckslhyhh6d533jc25xncl, and the whole nostr:nprofile1qyf8wumn8ghj7cnfw3ehgctrdvhxzursqythwumn8ghj7cmp9ehhyctwvajhq6tvdshxgetkqqs0rxy6jmt44guxkny8z4pkym9mxckqxfytygxuntjn6l80hj409sggjrzcm team on 100 editions of the Financial Freedom Report. If you're not signed up, this is one of the few newsletters I read from top to bottom. https://hrf.org/program/financial-freedom/financial-freedom-reports/

Finally, on the last day of the Africa Bitcoin Conference, I've saved the worst CBDC experience in Africa for last: Nigeria. In the words of the Central Bank of Nigeria, the CBDC experience has not been a "rosy story." The central bank launched the eNaira in 2021, and it's basically been downhill since then. Initial adoption was stuck at just 0.5 percent. The central bank lowered the requirements for access and introduced discounts in response, but people still preferred cash over the CBDC. With adoption still struggling, Central Bank of Nigeria deputy governor Kingsley Obiora said that all the eNaira needs is a “a little push from the government.” That's when the central bank suddenly announced it was taking cash out of circulation. After lines turned to protests and then riots, the central bank described the eNaira as a "success" after adoption went from 0.5% to 6%. https://www.coindesk.com/opinion/2023/03/06/nigerians-rejection-of-their-cbdc-is-a-cautionary-tale-for-other-countries Even the IMF admit the CBDC has largely been a failure. In a 2023 study, the IMF found that 98.5 percent of the wallets issued have never been used. And that's to say nothing of all the complaints on the app stores. https://x.com/EconWithNick/status/1942230482995048751?s=20 The eNaira has largely fallen apart at this point. Speaking in Ghana a few weeks ago, one Central Bank of Nigeria official said that Nigerians were not interested in the CBDC, the central bank was not prepared to be a retail bank, and the market was already providing solutions. I've only just skimmed the surface, so be sure to check out the nostr:nprofile1qyf8wumn8ghj7cnfw3ehgctrdvhxzursqythwumn8ghj7cmp9ehhyctwvajhq6tvdshxgetkqqs0rxy6jmt44guxkny8z4pkym9mxckqxfytygxuntjn6l80hj409sggjrzcm CBDC Tracker to learn more about what's happening in Africa, Europe, Asia, and elsewhere. https://cbdctracker.hrf.org/home

After hearing the Bank Secrecy Act would be too expensive to comply with, Congress brought in "experts" to say how much it will cost. Congress: Would you agree that bankers exagerate the cost? The Expert: Oh, I have no idea.

It's day two of #ABC2025 so let's look at some of the pilot projects in Africa by digging into what's been happening in Mauritius, Tunisia, and Ghana. The Bank of Mauritius received assistance from the IMF to research CBDCs back in 2020. After 4 years of research, the central bank launched a pilot in 2024. Details, however, have been pretty limited. It only said one commercial bank was involved and more pilots would follow. The Banque Centrale de Tunisie had an early start in 2019 when rumors spread that it launched a CBDC, but the central bank quickly denied these claims. It did, however, launch a CBDC pilot in collaboration with the Banque de France in 2021 to test cross-border transactions. The Bank of Ghana also got its start in 2019. It ran a pilot in 2022 and planned to go live in 2023, but it delayed those plans due to the high inflation experienced at the time. The central bank continues to be active in the space, but the timeline is unclear. Tomorrow, I'll spotlight the only launched CBDC in Africa. However, if you can't wait... you can find out who it is in the nostr:nprofile1qyf8wumn8ghj7cnfw3ehgctrdvhxzursqythwumn8ghj7cmp9ehhyctwvajhq6tvdshxgetkqqs0rxy6jmt44guxkny8z4pkym9mxckqxfytygxuntjn6l80hj409sggjrzcm CBDC Tracker. https://cbdctracker.hrf.org/

I couldn't make it to #ABC2025, but I'm there in spirit. So for anyone else stuck at home, let's look at some of the African countries in the nostr:nprofile1qyf8wumn8ghj7cnfw3ehgctrdvhxzursqythwumn8ghj7cmp9ehhyctwvajhq6tvdshxgetkqqs0rxy6jmt44guxkny8z4pkym9mxckqxfytygxuntjn6l80hj409sggjrzcm CBDC Tracker that are researching CBDCs: Botswana, Namibia, and Kenya. The Bank of Botswana kicked off its CBDC exploration in 2021. However, a central bank official confirmed this summer that they are still "at an early stage of exploration." The Bank of Namibia began its research in 2020 and eventually received assistance from the IMF on at least three different occasions. However, in 2024, the IMF “did not find a strong case for issuing a [retail CBDC] at the moment." The Central Bank of Kenya had a bit of a late start in 2022, but it has repeatedly found that CBDCs are a solution in search of a problem. The central bank said many of Kenya's problems "cannot be solved with CBDCs" and that launching a CBDC is not "a compelling priority." Curious to learn more? You can find more information in the HRF CBDC Tracker. And tomorrow, I'll spotlight the pilot projects. https://cbdctracker.hrf.org/home

If you run or work in financial services (banking, bitcoin, or anything else) in the Eurozone, dm me! I'm working on a follow-up to my piece calling out the ECB's "freedom money" campaign, and the perspective on the ground would be very helpful here.

Did you know Peru has 7.9 million sols ($2.36 million) in CBDC in circulation? https://cbdctracker.hrf.org/

Something to be thankful for: the South African Reserve Bank has officially announced "that while a retail CBDC is technically feasible ... there is no compelling immediate need for its implementation." More details here: https://cbdctracker.hrf.org

In a moment of reflection, Central Bank of Nigeria official Musa Itopa Jimoha admit that the Nigerian CBDC experience had not been a "rosy story." Nigerians were not interested in the eNaira because the market was already providing solutions. He warned other central banks not to issue a CBDC unless there is a real problem that it will actually solve. Interestingly, he also advised creating a separate legal entity to handle the CBDC so that operations are not directly under the central bank. cbdctracker.hrf.org

If the ECB were concerned about the freedom to choose, it would have been campaigning for decades to remove financial restrictions and let new options flourish. Instead, what it’s really after is control. https://www.cato.org/blog/digital-euro-isnt-about-freedom

The ECB planning to force Apple to crack open its secure element is really all you need to know when it comes to whether you should trust the digital euro.

The ECB has picked up a new buzzword for its digital euro campaign: “freedom.” But don't be fooled, CBDCs are about control, not freedom. https://www.cato.org/blog/digital-euro-isnt-about-freedom

While discussing the Bank Secrecy Act, Representative Patman said the quiet part out loud. He congratulated the Treasury for going "rather far" and "making a long step here" to establish capital controls. The Treasury quickly shot back saying not to call it that.

Ah, yes, because the worst-case scenario is that people's needs are satisfied by the market.

More than half of the authoritarian regimes across the world are publicly working on CBDCs. https://cbdctracker.hrf.org

As part of its CBDC development, the United Arab Emirates just conducted its first "government financial transaction using Digital Dirham." https://cbdctracker.hrf.org

This is a wild exchange from the Bank Secrecy Act hearings in 1970. A member of Congress asks why innocent people need privacy, acknowledges Jewish people fleeing the holocaust, and then says "History is a lot of hogwash in this."

One of my favorite things about Bitcoin is that more people than ever are asking questions like, ‘What is money? What is privacy? What is sovereignty?’ It’s through that curiosity that people see what’s at stake. https://www.ccn.com/education/crypto/cbdcs-digital-euro-turn-money-into-control-nick-anthony/

It's a little funny promoting my Substack on here since followers get it directly cross-posted as reads. However, if you'd prefer my work in your inbox instead, sign up for my Substack where I cover CBDC developments, financial privacy, debanking, financial freedom, and more. Price of $0/₿0/₳0/€0/₦0/Kč0/₸0/¥0 https://bankingbureau.substack.com

Aimlessly wondering around Prague and I look up to find I’ve stumbled my way to the Czech Central Bank. It seems that even on my off days, I’m tracking central banks.