Paying off a mortgage early feels responsible, which is why the argument is so sticky.
You look at the payment, imagine it disappearing, and call that peace of mind. I get the appeal. Nobody likes owing money, and a paid-off house sounds like the cleanest possible version of adulting.
But a fixed-rate mortgage is strange debt. Your payment is locked in for decades while dollars keep getting cheaper, your income and assets may rise, and the real burden of that loan slowly gets lighter. The bank gave you long-term leverage on an asset you were probably going to buy anyway, and the terms cannot be yanked away because markets had a bad Tuesday.
The expensive part is what you give up. Extra principal payments earn whatever your mortgage rate is. That may be fine in isolation, but FIRE is about building a liquid asset base that can fund your life, cover bad years, and keep compounding while you still have choices.
A paid-off house can lower a bill, but it cannot buy groceries unless you borrow against it or sell it. Bitcoin, stocks, and cash can be sold in pieces. That flexibility is security too.
I wrote about why the mortgage payoff comfort story can make FIRE harder, especially when liquid assets and bitcoin are the better source of optionality: 

🧘 Peace of Mind
FIRE BTC #40 - Why paying off your mortgage early makes you poorer
















