I drive trucks two days a week as my off-the-farm job to keep things stable. While I drive the trucks, I listen to @jack mallers Mailbag Monday.
I appreciate his macro takes and his ability to see the truth of so many different situations. But one thing he keeps saying rubs me the wrong way: it's a moral imperative for a company to be profitable—that profit means you're producing more value than you extract from the market.
In a free market, he's right.
But we don't have a free market in food.
Four meatpackers control 85% of U.S. beef processing. Ranchers now take home less than 30 cents of every retail beef dollar. Since 2015, cattle prices have dropped while grocery prices have climbed. The processors in the middle are recording record profits. That's not value creation rewarded by a free market—that's extraction protected by a captured one.
The rancher raising the best grassfed beef in the county often can't legally sell it. Federal law requires USDA inspection for retail meat sales, and there are only about 90 USDA slaughter facilities in the entire country. Some states have none. Custom-processed meat must be stamped "NOT FOR SALE." So the highest-value local beef either can't reach the consumer at all or gets funneled into commodity channels at undifferentiated commodity prices—prices set by the same four companies that control the market.
In this system, profitability doesn't measure value. It measures compliance with the captured and extractive system. The ones most able to externalize their costs (on the land, on the animals, on the workers, on their families, etc.) are the most "profitable."
The median American farm household earned negative $1,830 from farming in 2024. Negative. Ninety-six percent of farm households earn off-farm income to survive. Statistically, ALL OF THEM.
The median farm family brings in $87,000 from off-farm jobs—not government handouts, but second and third jobs—to keep farming and feeding people.
That's not a moral failing. That might be the most noble act in the American economy: someone who knows the math doesn't work, keeps feeding people anyway, and drives to town to work a second job to make it possible.
They're not extracting from the market. They're subsidizing it—with their own labor, their own time, their own bodies.
If profitability is a moral imperative, then we need a market worthy of the morality.
#foodfreedom #farming #ranching #foodstr #farmstr
jsm
_@studiohill.farm
npub17fay...lnh4
Farmer.
Presently integrating a project I'm working on with Strike's API for instant global payouts to farmers.
Congrats @jack mallers
Love this.
View quoted note →
Broth season.


Upvember?
Institutions will always protect the paradigms that give them meaning.


GM.
Work toward your 10-year goals today.
Start, maybe, by writing down your 10-year goals.
GM
I'm only watching for @jack's T-shirt.
GM
GM.
GM. Watch your step today.


GN all.
GN
Subzero sheep chores.
#farming #regenerativeagriculture #sheep


@Vitor Pamplona I see a spot to add a new reaction symbol in #Amethyst. But what do I type or paste in there that will add something? I would like to add a heart. Thanks! #asknostr
Hey y'all. Happy ATH day! How about a generational-gift to celebrate your new generational wealth?
View article →
We're launching a $2.2 million loan campaign for Chapul Farms in a few minutes. Join us at 3pm ET to watch a community of real people finance #regenerativeagriculture.


Steward
Grant Reimbursement Loan For Chapul Farms - Chapul Farms | Steward
Chapul Farms won a $3.9M USDA grant to expand production of organic soil amendments with insect agriculture. This loan is an advance on that grant ...