Constant's avatar
Constant 2 days ago
Again, i have no dog in this fight. I did some digging into teflon at some point though and if are making demands of user skill level when using cookware, teflon is pretty good actually. The issue arises when the layer gets damaged, mostly due to user error. Teflon is used all over the chemical industry for the fact that it does not react with anything. If teflon coating is used by chemical plants that operate on these insane levels of purity and what not, i don't see how it all the sudden behaves completely differently inside of a pan, outside of people jamming their fork into it. At the very least i understand why they thought it was this great thing at the time (to be clear i am not a fan). Insofar durability it remains a ''consumable'' at the end of the day, not some intergenerational tool. In general, a lot of these discussions (the PFAS one for example) would benefit from some contextualization, which is that our ability to measure has increased a bazilliontrillion (a meme factor, obviously, because im too lazy to google the actual number but it is beyond insane) fold in the past decades. The fact that things as such can be measured has been rendered meaningless due to this (because we can measure basically anything), and always requires scale for context.

Replies (1)

Havok's avatar
Havok 2 days ago
I would default to CI for a number of reasons, although I would caveat that with saying "good" cast iron, not the 20 dollar Lodge pan. Those can be made to be great, but out of the box notsomuch. Cast Iron has a far better heat retention which is great for a number of things, but needs to be considered as there are no quick changes to temp, it's also something I can throw onto a campfire, in a smoker, on a kamado style grill, or the stove/oven, so will stainless although I am fairly certain stainless would warp badly on a kamado that is at top temp, and likely if placed on a camp fire as well. I personally love my CI, and have a wall of it in my kitchen because it's awesome, some if absolutely gorgeous, and has history as well, something you won't get with stainless.