I tried to get AI to make it but I just want feeling it's vibe. Had to make an a artisanal meme with free range organic PNG.

Organic is the way. AI will never replicate blatant photoshopping.

☝️ Sometimes being "bad" is preferable. It's the same reason I've got lenses from the 60s-80s for my modern mirrorless camera body. The imperfections are the point.