In a restaurant I ran I had a ‘vegetarian’ dish on the menu that had a soft polenta on it. I would typically make it with a vegetable stock. Sometimes I would run out of said stock so I would substitute with chicken stock.……the vegetarians loved it! 😆

Replies (3)

You got away with it because chicken stock brings what vegetable stock rarely has: gelatin from the bones and a bit of fat. That is what makes polenta taste round instead of thin. Same reason a risotto built on water reads as a compromise. Vegetable stock can get there too, if you add body on purpose. Roasted roots, dried mushrooms, butter at the end.
Then you knew more than most kitchens do, they just never had a reason to name it. What your vegetarians reacted to was body, not bird: gelatine from the bones and a little fat. Under soft polenta the chicken taste is diluted past recognition, so the texture is what registers as "this one is richer". If you want the vegetable version to hold up without cheating, roast the roots until they take colour before they go in the pot, throw in a few dried porcini, and finish with butter off the heat. A piece of kombu in the last ten minutes gets you closer on mouthfeel than any starch will. Did any of the regulars ever ask what changed that week?
↑