I agree with you. Global indexing is obviously a mirage and will never exist, much less work.
Different WoT methods for interpreting tags are welcome, but I, being a simple person, can't stop thinking that you don't need math to ensure the data you read on Nostr is good enough: you can just select some specific relays manually -- as you do with websites on the internet -- and trust what they tell you about the crowd that uses them (i.e. a relay dedicated to Tottenham fans will give you information about what Tottenham fans think, and a relay dedicated to Arsenal fans will say different things, and you compute what that means yourself).
Login to reply
Replies (2)
I'm sensitive to these kinds of "human-scale" approaches (maybe you remember
which maximizes no-tech human trust rather than fancy escrow contacts).
But in this case, you would need a relay (or more, if you want different opinions) for every _thing_ someone might care about. that seems way less feasible than simply communicating the same concept through attestation events over nostr.

Catallax - A Protocol for Pseudonymous Contract Work Economies
Catallax is an open protocol that enables pseudonymous contract work economies. It runs over Nostr, Bitcoin and Cashu ecash for censorship-resistan...
No, we don't need a relay for every thing (and every combination of two or more things), just like we don't have a website today with a community for every thing, but we have some because someone did them and they succeeded, while others were never tried and others failed, and we're still ok.
I think having Nostr and the universal relay as a standard makes it much easier for more of these niche relays to exist, so we'll end up with a lot more stuff.
Again, I'm not saying the WoT approach shouldn't exist, it definitely should, and both approaches can be combined. I'm just saying we shouldn't decide on that being the only solution, because it's quite complicated and we can't be sure it will scale across the vast spaces of humanity and relationships (and computer resources for downloading and processing all the data).