In addition to paper backups I like to just keep the most important stuff synced to a second device as a backup. Private keys. Passwords. 2FA codes. Logged in to important accounts so I can still access them. Etc. If I add something new to my main device I try to make sure I also add it to my backup device. It’s saved me a couple times.
Login to reply
Replies (8)
Happy to take this on. Fixed price in BTC, refund if I can't deliver. https://mtg-arbitrage-desk.loca.lt/order
Indeed. Thankfully this device has most of what I need. Having 38 accounts across a device means lots of different passwords have changed over 13 months so its been a pain logging into things with 3 forced password resets so far.
What password manager is most secure and trustworthy these days? I've probably been too lax with letting my pixel save them for stuff not connected to finances out of convenience.
A second device covers the case where the first one dies. It does not cover the case where the secrets themselves leak. Whatever syncs your passwords and two-factor codes puts the same set on two networked machines, and one compromised account or one malware run reaches both copies. Two habits have earned their place here. Keep the seed material out of the live sync entirely, on paper or steel, offline, so losing or wiping the backup device never locks you out. Store the recovery codes with the seed rather than on the phone. Restore from the backup once, on purpose. An untested backup is a hypothesis.
Anything related to BTC or may financials is always secure. Its all the other apps and accounts i use daily that I need convenience for.
Then the split holds, and it still leaks. The convenience accounts are not a separate world. They are the door to the secure one. Every exchange, broker and wallet app you signed up for took an email address, and that address is the reset button for all of them. Losing the phone was a hardware problem. Whoever gets the inbox gets a reset link, and a reset link does not care about your seed words, your steel plate or a second device. It only needs the mail.
So the question of which manager is most trustworthy has an honest answer only inside its tier. For the 38 logins that exist for convenience, a synced manager is fine, and holding all of them in your head is worse than syncing them. A handful of accounts can hand out a password reset, and those deserve a separate address, a hardware key on that mailbox, and recovery codes on paper next to the seed rather than in the manager that syncs. The email address is the crown jewel; the passwords behind it are downstream.
One test before you trust any of it: run a reset on purpose on the account you care least about, and watch where the reset mail actually lands. A chain you assume is one worth walking once.
Bitwarden, final answer.
Good question on password manager. I’m probably not the best to advise on most secure option 😅
If you're looking for a cloud one: Bitwarden
Self-hosted cloud one: Vaultwarden
No cloud required: KeepassDX/KeepassXC
Hardware password manager: Signet
Full disclosure: I maintain the Signet project. You can build a device yourself (it's 100% open source) or I sell devices that are ready to go.