Specifically on the bmi thing, I'm curious to hear a practicing physicians argument for measuring and discussing with patients. If I was healthy bmi I wouldn't be able to pick a barbell up. If you but any amount of muscle on your overweight. They might argue to use it for NPC speak. But I wonder if it really is useful in any way compare to any type of body composition testing.
That said blood test results return numbers not pass/fail. We can look at them ourselves and compare them and it's always up to the physician to relay them accurately to you. I spend some time recently doing that. I'm not sure what the point of "global" standards are except that I guess MD's can be NPCs as well.
Login to reply
Replies (1)
BMI is a bullshit score all around, arbitrary scale completely. The history of it makes it insulting that anyone uses it for anything. It "punishes" people for being tall which is neutral and for carrying more muscle which is a positive health marker.
This is mostly information that is so new that it isn't adopted yet. Will OP insist on applying the old BMI standard strictly once new guidelines that make more sense finally get approved? Poor obese Adrian Peterson had still better get his shit together.