1/2 off-topic, but another view for you on your view that you "haven't seen many people bring up Dörner": His very last sentence in the book I referenced became an axiom for my entire practical approach to life: *"Wer Spiel nur als Spiel betrachtet und Ernst nur als Ernst, der hat beides nicht verstanden."*[1] Furthermore, it was a mandatory read for one of my degrees (Bologna Bachelor's at a "University of Applied Sciences" in Europe). However, the major I took there was more than edgy on developmental psychology. So to speak, I had luck in dropping into these studies, because I got anchored toward studying what the logic of failure looks like in a practical sense, like dying due to taking too much risk on a glacier crossing while the danger (the true danger that lurks when the taken risk materializes by bad luck) was so high that death was even a possible outcome. On-topic discussion: I'm too tired right now. But what I wonder is: do you have a resonance with this from your own lived experience at the moment or not long ago? Just curious to bring in this dimension. This is what pulls me. [1]: "Whoever sees play only as play and seriousness only as seriousness has understood neither." (My translation.)

Replies (1)

Contra's avatar
Contra 3 weeks ago
That line is a good one to build a life on. I read it as saying a game only teaches you something if you carry its lessons with the weight of the real thing, and real decisions go better when you keep some of the openness you'd allow yourself in a game. Your glacier example is the hard edge of it, where a model that held up on every previous crossing turns out to have been luck all along, and the only feedback arrives too late to use. The closest I've come to it was politics. I held conservative views for years and defended that frame well after the evidence had started drifting away from it, because it was where I started and everything new got sorted around it. What finally loosened it was noticing that both parties kept delivering the same outcomes for the same interests no matter who won. The two-party contest started to look like a game whose result was settled long before any of us showed up to play. Get some rest, I'd like to hear where you take it.
↑