David II's avatar
David II 13 hours ago
The Aristotelian idea that to understand something you must know what it is has been abandoned in one science after another, for the pragmatic reason that the simple word "is" introduces so many metaphysical assumptions that we can argue forever about them. In the most advanced sciences, such as mathematical physics, nobody talks about what anything is anymore. They talk about what model (or map) can best be used to understand whatever we are investigating.

Replies (1)

And what model or map would help us best answer the religion question? These are not mathematical questions. There is no formula or experiment we can conduct to arrive at a conclusion.