I’m simply sharing there is more to it than material considerations. The holidays weren’t selected to have convenient days to plant or plan. My perceptions are still very limited, but even I can detect differences in consciousness depending on time of year. Holidays were set up by mystics understanding of cycles and forces not city planners. They were a time to share mystery dramas, do ritual magic, and interact with higher worlds in a way less accessible on other days. You didn’t call on anyone to change their traditions. However I am calling on those who know or are learning, to modify their expressions of those holidays as they learn. I’ve got a lot of planning to do to get ready for the 12 holy nights. January 6 (Joan of Arc birthday) is a pretty special day for initiation. I don’t see mass meditation being practiced that day. So I plan to focus on the reclamation of important days rather than why they got messed up. Hopefully next fall equinox I can do more than meditate in the park for a couple hours. The popular celebration is pumpkin spice latte at a carnival or pumpkin patch. We can do better.

Replies (1)

It seems like Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs and basic economic calculus isn't included in your conception of how holidays came to be. Frankly, neither of us can honestly assert why the holidays came to be what they are with anything remotely resembling full confidence, however, some narrative explanations of how the holidays came to be are very logical and others are not at all logical. I am prone to go with the logical narrative that accounts for things like sustenance, survival, and praxeological considerations. First, the astrological markers are established, i.e. solstices and equinoxes. Eventually those become associated with growing and harvesting seasons. The anchoring of growing and harvesting cues to equinoxes and solstices was a way for people to improve their yields/harvests. Eventually, the knowledge of why the holidays became largely, if not entirely, lost and the holidays themselves remained. The association with fertility remained for example, the Easter/Esther/Ishtar celebration which is tied to the Vernal equinox. Then people unskilled in the application of the Golden Rule started engaging in post hoc ergo propter hoc logical fallacies and chose to associate their greater harvests not with intelligent planning but rather with divine intervention. That leads to all sorts of weird, nonsensical rituals and insane justifications for them that often become ossified into tradition. I mean...just look at how far baptism has come. The distortions are literally ridiculous. Over a billion people practice baptism today and think they're doing something but the truth is that what they're doing is a hollow shell of the original ritual. Holidays are the same.