I have something from the fediverse to add to @jack 's post here: View quoted note → This positive attitude about building stuff is really great to see on Nostr and it does not exist on the fediverse at all. Since most ActivityPub implementations are heavy it's unreasonable to expect most users to self host. So people tend to gather into communities based on their chosen instance (think: website they are actually using). The different AP implementations really only work together in spite of each other, and there's endless drama about what your chosen AP software says about you, be you a contributor, administrator, or just a user. For example, here's some hilarious beef I saw today between Mastodon instances. The instance mastodon.art is notorious for blocking an absurd number of instances, to the point where artists looking to get commissioned work should really not post there. They wrote this blog post about how they are defederating from another growing instance because they implemented text based search (for public posts) and a few other less important complaints: You heard that right. This is about the indexing of publicly available posts. As though it's some kind of terrible harassment tool. Remember that ActivityPub supports followers-only posts and follow approvals. Consider also this instance is for artists, who WANT to be found. That's just drama between Mastodon instances. When it comes to the other implementations it gets even more insufferable. ActivityPub is a protocol like Nostr, but people building on Nostr actually like each other. Celebrate that.

Replies (6)

It’s true, so many ppl on fedi are completely deranged and the censorship may be even worse than Twitter. Fedi also fails at decentralisation given how concentrated users are on the large instances.
I think nostr is more resiliant to the infighting found on the fediverse. However I think good old fashion network effects will keep people on Twitter, even through this rate limiting nonsense. Either way I find these alternative spaces more exciting so here I am.
Default avatar
Enrico 2 years ago
Protocols with the right incentives win over centralized apps in the long run.
Fwiw I think we solve a lot of the structural problems of centralized services quite well. The model we have serves the 'internet town square' idea much better than any single company can deliver. It's just a matter of developing some real staying power for when new people show up.