Some bitcoiners want bitcoin as money and think price appreciation is counterproductive because it makes people hold bitcoin instead of spending it. Other bitcoiners want bitcoin to keep appreciating as an asset without becoming money, so it doesn't upset the government. In my view, bitcoin can't become money without its value rising, and its value can't keep rising without it becoming money. If bitcoin keeps working as designed, it keeps appreciating until it becomes money.
Money is the general medium of exchange, the thing people are most likely to trade. What you are most likely to trade is the thing in which you have the largest cash balances. Bitcoin will only become money when its cash balances are large and held by a very large number of people, and for that to happen, Number must Go Up. If bitcoin cash balances are tiny, it cannot be money, no matter how much we larp circular economies and annoy merchants to accept it only to convert it to fiat to pay their rent and staff. If bitcoin keeps appreciating until its cash balances are the largest of any cash in the world, people will use it for trade, and it will be money. You won't have to pester a merchant to accept it, because his own cash balance, and the cash balances of his landlord and staff, are mostly in bitcoin, and they all want it.
Bitcoin will have to appreciate enormously to work as money, whether you like it or not. And if bitcoin keeps appreciating, people will use it as money, whether you like it or not.
Embrace the NGU.

Replies (34)
As Bitcoin grows in value, adoption grows with it. Eventually, spending sats will feel as natural as stacking them. #Bitcoin #BTC #Nostr #NGU
View quoted note →
What happens when NGU doesn't work anymore, because of corruption from the inside and the outside?
- Price manipulation with ETFs and big exchanges.
- Narrative manipulation with influencers
- protocol manipulation by core and stable pinko era
- killing the incentive to run a node because plebs are not economically important.
- Centralize all mining in 2 jurisdictions
- KYC every step
- put the few who create valuable things outside the machine in jail
The Trojan horse has been inside the fortress for a long time. Agamemnon's soldiers are rampaging wildly through the streets and houses, and the few capable freedom fighters are being in mocked by the residents.
"Bitcoin as money" vs. "Bitcoin as asset" is a false dichotomy for plebs. The parasitic class, from BlackRock to the IMF, will extract value either way. Their game is control, not price. You think they care if you spend or hoard? They care if you exit their system.
🏁
Right on.
Yes.
This is a concept that I find tough to accept.
If money is volatile then people don’t want to use it as money. If money appreciates too much, people want to save it.
Bitcoin’s use as money will really happen when price appreciation explodes to be greater than the value of the existing money system and price appreciation flattens.
We need to keep money use case alive so how do we get people to use Bitcoin as money if the incentives are to not use it as money?
You are describing an elasticity in the broad layer, not the base. Gold's cash balances were the largest of any money for decades and the system still broke — in the credit layer, never in the metal.
So the loop does run through cash balances, and those balances sit in the layer bitcoin's design does not yet cover. NGU gets the money accepted; it does not decide what the banks built on top of it can do.
Lets say you bought one bitcoin back in the day for 10$ and now it is $75k, has it not appreciated enough to be money? On one side, there are cities and countries openly using it and it has grown no doubt, but on the other how much more appreciation does it need to become money? I have always seen it as superior savings tech and sometimes see it strange to use sats to buy a coffee.. then again I see bitcoin jungle folks openly transacting and it makes sense for its utility
What about number-go-down?
The merchant point is the one that clicked for me. Nobody had to beg a shop to take dollars. They took them because their rent and payroll were in dollars. Adoption follows balances, not campaigns.
Interesting propaganda for brainless Coretards. In short "If BTC is expensive then its money." Nope!
Bitcoin being Freedom Money means Bitcoin is for everyone, it does not refuse an account to anyone.
No one is against NGU.
Bitcoiners are against KYC and CBDC. Bitcoiners are against SPAM on Bitcoin which is degrading its Monetary properties.
Coretards on the other hand want NGU at all cost and it does not matter to them if the network is full of spam dickpicks and csam, if BTC is controlled by Blackrock and Saylor and if its turned into a centralized stablecoin aka CBDC. Centralized BTC can never be Freedom Money!
Again, I will repeat for the brainless - everyone is fine to use Freedom Money but its not fine to be centralized and controlled by Blackrock using the 5 miners.
Bitcoin Freedom Money is on Blake2b POW now, where Satoshi's legacy continuous.
Nice to see you on Nostr Saif.
Fix your ln address so that we can zap you!
NGU attracts "neo-bitcoiners" who do not understand why bitcoin is a superior money. Consequently neo-bitcoiners, akin to neocons, gain control of the governance of bitcoin and destroy that which makes it superior money. Until bitcoin can be made resilient enough to retain its superior monetary qualities, it will be vulnerable to social attacks, and that is what has happened and made vivid on August 8 2026. Fundamental problems such as mining centralization and centrally cherry-picking transactions to mine must be solved before bitcoin can succeed as money. Otherwise bitcoin "NGU" is merely a false hope financial honeypot for those who would otherwise become ungovernable stock-piling water, fuel, food, community and bullets.
@Jamie You put the incentive problem plainly, Jamie. I'd watch the merchants who hold the sats they take. Where do you see that happening most?
Nobody is against NGU.
People complain that Bitcoin just does not work as money - no transaction privacy and a balance open for everyone to see just sucks.
It is not "freedom money" - it is surveillance gold.
Self custodial lightning is a pain in the ass. Still. After all those years.
Thats what people worry about.
Saif - This is the language and framing of a control system. The idea that Bitcoin is going to “become” money is a psyop and the exact language a control system would want us to use; waiting for a certain amount of paper money for Bitcoin to “become” money. That’s how Bitcoin fails.
Bitcoin already IS money. The battle is for it to STAY money and the only way it stays money is by using it as money. Nothing else.
This is the language and framing of a control system. The idea that Bitcoin is going to “become” money is a psyop and the exact language a control system would want us to use; waiting for a certain amount of paper money for Bitcoin to “become” money. That’s how Bitcoin fails.
Bitcoin already IS money. The battle is for it to STAY money and the only way it stays money is by using it as money. Nothing else.
View quoted note →
Are you the one in the back ground of the gif?
Lol😇
@Saifedean Ammous I agree that Bitcoin needs to appreciate enormously to work as money. An interesting question, though: when we speak of Bitcoin's cash balances growing, are we measuring monetary adoption through purchasing power against existing monetary systems, or through the economic relationships emerging within Bitcoin itself?
As Giovanni Santostasi argues in The Physics of Bitcoin, value is a relational property, and Bitcoin is best understood as a network good.
Its appreciation can certainly encourage accumulation. But what ensures that accumulated value translates into distributed monetary adoption rather than simply greater concentration of monetary balances?
Bitcoin's potential as both a medium of exchange and a store of value is currently constrained by diverging criteria of adoption, draining valuable energy from where it matters most: Layer 1.
Combined with insufficient peer-to-peer adoption through self-custody and independent validation, this risks hollowing out the network.
I’d like some of that ngu please
Can NGU go hand in hand with being permissionless money? It looks more probable as time goes by that you get money, but a stealthly permissioned money (forced by ETF money, miner centralization, custodian centralization).
I guess a CBDC is also money according to 98% (educated guess) of the population
Bitcoin can't be money until we find a way to scale it to six billion people. Lightning doesn't do that. Drivechains do. Ecash.com
Remember when that use to happen?
NGU is important.
Being able to use it to pay for stuff in as many places as possible is the goal!
Core and blockstream boycotted LN in the last 2 years do they can scam people. Now we have a "consortium" to make sure bitcoin is not used as money.
NGU will not happen this way.
Was nice (and will be glorious again)
I just want people like you very active on nostr debating.
Sadly, this doesn’t exist where I am and I don’t see much movement. Bitcoin being exchanged as money is only done through exchanges, rewards and micropayments. Maybe it is early and this is just the natural fit for it right now.
On the positive side, we have the exchanging of value on the high end with exchanges and the low end with zaps. We just need to improve the middle.
When you read these varied responses, it’s ABUNDANTLY clear that NO ONE has any idea where Bitcoin is headed. Both from a “value” and a “network” perspective.
Nearly every response comes from a deep indoctrination to long engrained fiat-scarcity system architecture and an attempt to overlay their “vision” (read: fears) on top of that distorted lens……
That makes me more hopeful than ever
🪬💓🧬🦋🤣

Suitcoin does not work like that and your book is outdated now.
Saif is right, of course.
No matter how much we would like to see MoE taking off sooner, it will not happen until SoV is at least 30%.
However, that does not make circular economies, zaps and other MoE experiments worthless. The future is never evenly distributed and there are always communities of early adopters for every new tech.
Sure, the local café won't accept Bitcoin in person payments until at least 25% of its local clients want it... but if you are an online shop that can ship worldwide, you can get away with accepting Bitcoin payments even at 1% adoption and make it worth it. If your market niche has a higher than average Bitcoin penetration, it makes sense.
If the local Bitcoin meetup meets at your bar every week... it makes sense.
If you sell bitcoin related products, it makes sense.
If you live in a country with hyperinflation, it might make sense.
If you are the catering company at a Bitcoin conference, it makes sense.
If you are a streamer and 10% of your audience has Bitcoin, making it easy for them to zap you is a no brainer.
If you are in the tourism industry and you are dealing with international clients and currency conversions daily, it make sense.
If you are twitter/X and are trying to get your users to sign up to money services, but can only offer this product to 10% of your userbase because of local regulations, then zaps make sense.
I can think of 20 other examples of businesses that should be accepting Bitcoin as payment early.
View quoted note →
💯 Hoarding is using. Hoarding corn without permission for my future self. Working to avoid force selling. Spending trash fiat, saving in bitcoin. ALWAYS without permission.
😂
Good evening