I fail to see how dice roll generated seed airgap inserted is affected? What am I missing? Is there more amiss than the RNG on coldcards?
Login to reply
Replies (7)
Agreed. It's just the RNG that is the issue. Coldcards would still be safe if that bug didn't exist.
Doing an emergency transfer of UTXO’s can bring it’s own problems. I have a compromised CC part of a multi vendor multisig.
I’m not touching the CC anymore and will make a new setup in due time.
If you are not directly affected I advise to sit on your hands first.
I guess anyone who has been promoting Coldcards is feeling a degree of guilt/responsibility right now and is possibly being a little excessive with their recommendations.
It's more that someone who would fuck up the encryption on a Bitcoin wallet should be assumed to be generally incompetent.
100 dice rolls on a single sig with a *strong* passphrase is not a single point of failure
so where to store funds then?
This is the right thing to do. There has been some more verification on dice rolls on a Coldcard so anyone who did 100 rolls is safe from this attack, and even more so with a strong passphrase. I think Odell's anger is getting the best of him, he should not be telling *everyone* with a Coldcard regardless of their setup to move their Bitcoin. He is already regretful of advise he has given, he will likely regret this too if people get scared and make mistakes by rushing when they don't even need to do anything 
