They should be called out if they say something that is untrue. But what is a nostr client? What makes a client a nostr client? Does it make sense to enforce what one can call a nostr client? I agree that you shall not compare apples to oranges. But also nostr was built for a reason. Other clients that does not fully support that idea shall miss something, otherwise the original idea of benefit of nostr does not hold. If they have a benefit, they shall outcompete others with that benefit, or? (Not this easy I know) Also it does not help, that it is not that general, that people use social media with spending X amount per month. Social media is free in the eyes of many.

Replies (1)

jb55's avatar
jb55 _@jb55.com 9 months ago
A nostr client connects directly to relays via websockets and pulls down notes via the nip01 specification. This is the bare minimum. If you don’t do this you’re not a nostr client. Imagine creating a web browser that doesn’t connect to web server directly. Instead you connect to a central server that makes the request for you and completely MITMs you, losing all verification. This server can tell you what sites you’re allowed to visit, and will randomly stop working when the server goes down. You wouldn’t call this a web browser (aka web client). It’s just not the same thing. People who build real web browsers would be frustrated that they are marketing themselves as the best new web browser for the http protocol. People trying the web for the first time get spied on, censored, and generally have a slow and unreliable expeirence. Now they think: wow the world wide web sucks and leaves. This is why it’s important to use words properly and not let people affinity attack well defined terms.