but its not the state, its the idea, and the beings that follow that idea and the book. there is no such thing as the good jew. if they were good, they wouldn't be a jew. its a paradox. similarly you can say there is no good rapist, and etc. being jewish is not a normal and neutral thing. if someone who identifies as jew is a good person(without any hidden agenda), then they are not a jew, because to be good they should stop following the "religion".

I don't believe that. I could say the same about protestants but that would be wild and unfounded.