Replies (59)
A lot of self-proclaimed capitalists are just insensitive selfish people.
And more uneducated than they thought, true.
Bleeding is a symptom, not the disease. Central bank balance sheets expanded 400% since 2008. Fiat is a managed decline. Bitcoin is the only viable exit.
You do know that bitcoin is a free market (capitalist) technology right?
If you're not here just to troll you should definitely sell all of your bitcoin because it's evil. I'm sure you knew that already though because you're so well read.
Bitcoin is open source. Free market and capitalism are not synonymous. Bitcoin is the antithesis of capitalism.
How do you define capitalism?
A economic system that is incentivized by and focuses on profits. Its core tenets focus on property rights, limited State intervention, and self interest being the main force behind market movements. The belief that competition is the best way to achieve efficiency.
Capitalism is also by design seeks to centralize control over production, resources, and capital.
Bitcoin is not free market.
Bitcoin is Proof of Work.
Capitalism isn't Proof of Work.
Capitalism is Proof of Stake.
Please provide a definition of capitalism, because saying it's proof of stake is just an analogy.
Would you consider yourself a communist?
I want to answer this one, and I will, but unfortunately it will be later this evening.
No, but I can definitely see the logic to the evolution to some of its ideology.
This is a very short definition of capitalism.
The more capital you have, the more power and control you have. Just like Bitcoin, the more Bitcoin you have, the more control and power you have over the Bitcoin blockchain.

Smart choice there tbh, though a majority of what I saw on your feed was following communist rhetoric.
Setting that aside, you're not a communist, but you see capitalism as a problem. I wonder how you would choose to organize the economy without either system..
That is partially correct, though an individual with half or more the bitcoin in existence would have a lot of sway in the market, but could not change the blockchain's consensus rules without hashrate.
Your user name includes BTC and many of your posts have a bitcoin hashtag, but here it seems that you are saying bitcoin is a bad thing.
Would you say that you don't like bitcoin or do you own some?
Could you define communism for me?
I think an economy be organized by people, for the best of everyone when it has protections in place or protocols.
I’m a huge fan of worker cooperatives and non profits. It’s a false premise to think profits are needed for an economy to exist.
To your first part, that’s weird, so all I have to do is buy half or more of all the bitcoin and I can control the market?
Where did I say bitcoin was a “bad thing”?
I have great hope for Bitcoin and have owned some for a long time.
Communism in theory: The labor force rises up to seize the means of production, then hands the reigns over to the people. There is no state and no money.
Communism in practice: Capital is raised in a foreign country to stage a coup. The coup is carried out and then the militants who take power remain in power until a lot of people starve to death out of mismanagement.
Above you compared bitcoin to capitalism, which is correct, but up to this point you have said that capitalism is bad, so that's where I got confused.
Also based on this message it sounds like you haven't done much research on how bitcoin functions. Have you read The Bitcoin Stanard or any other books that explain it?
Good troll
I like the first and would agree.
But one could argue that what you describe is not actually communism ideology in practice.
Yes, I have read lots on Bitcoin. Did I misrepresent something? Is there some mechanism at play that doesn’t allow one entity to acquire 50% or more of the Bitcoin supply?
Do you have anything intelligent to add? It’s not required obviously but makes things more interesting.
Wanted to add that capitalism is bad, based on history and data we have at our disposal. I will give capitalism credit on creating a global market…however the means in which it did so are abhorrent.
Every communist says this, but every time communism is tried that's what happens. That line is a popular meme actually.

I don't even know where to begin with that, but I wish you luck on doing your own research. Feel free to listen to this if you would like, it might be helpful.

Spotify
Episode Eight: Bitcoin
The Holotropic Renaissance Lecture Series · Episode
I’m not a communist. This looks like a cycle of capitalism with your favorite Austrian economist of choice in the center.
Of course you know the answer. There is a mechanism that prohibits one entity from acquiring 50% or more of the Bitcoin. You do know the answer, right?
Why is it so common on Nostr when you start getting into an actual in depth discussion, most just leave because it’s gone past talking points or makes them uncomfortable?
Capitalism main goal is profit and centralizing the dynamics for more profit.
Capitalism is not defined by being a “peer to peer digital cash”.
yes
Capitalism working as Proof of Stake:

I would argue that's socialism, but saying it's proof of stake is a lazy metaphor at best. Likewise, saying bitcoin is proof of work is not correct.
Bitcoin utilizes proof of work to secure the network. Bitcoin can be described in many ways, but naming one of it's attributes is not sufficient for a definition.
After thinking about what you've said so far I do see your argument. It comes down to different definitions of terms. Historical capitalism could be considered closer to proof of stake than proof of work, but communism certainly isn't a solution to that.
I assume you are in favor of sound money and the free market though, correct?
“Historical capitalism” what is that? Who said anything about communism being a solution?
Sound money, yes. Free market…you would need to describe to me what you think free market is.
So, socialism is what is making the rich become richer?
🤣🤣🤣
Yes, actually. I've made some progress in understanding your position, so I'll try to elborate on mine.
Socialism, which I would define primarily through the use of taxation to redistribute wealth and control the behavior of the private sector, inherently relies upon some central governing body in order to manage this process (some people believe an LLM would do a better job, but I think that's horrifying)
As soon as an individual, democratically selected or otherwise, is put into such an office, they do two things:
1. Increase their own slice of the pie.
2. Misallocate capital.
This explains the revolving door between the private and public sector which has robbed the world blind. This also explains why the most socialist countries end up the poorest.
It is possible that you have a different definition of socialism, but I have yet to come across one which precludes compulsory taxation, bureaucratic government, and market manipulation.
Yep, the last thing I want is to fruits of my work to be evenly distributed. Fucking commies.
Oh I see your confusion. Nobody is taking the fruits of your labor like in capitalism. Socialists want to protect and make sure you are fairly compensated for your labor.
What you are experiencing in a common misconception of socialism by those who have not studied it or are trying to degrade it.
I will respond to this when I have time.
That is not socialism ideology at all. Which more socialist countries are you referring to for being the poorest? And, what factors are you using to calculate the “wealth” of a country?
Would you defined the USA as a socialist country?
For corporations, absolutely; for workers, absolutely not. That's where the inequalities really ramp up.
I would like to know how you define the socialist ideology. Your responses are starting to get a little confusing, and it certainly could be on my part.
May I ask what does it mean for you "to be socialist for corporations"?
🙄
In that they get bailed out by the public sector every time they make a mistake because they are "too big to fail" as a result of the central planning that created them.
All of this is well known; hardly a controversial take.
It is controversial. Unregulated capitalist banks corrupt and make shady investments. It blows up in their face, the whole world suffers. To stop the suffering society foots the bill and you blame socialism. Surely you see the folly in that logic.
The state protecting some corporations in bad times while letting them exploit workers and hoarding the wealth is not exactly socialism.
It's crony capitalism.
I would say it’s just the natural consequences of capitalism.
Two words for the same issue imo. How would you define socialism. Are you in favor of taxation?
I would describe socialism as the decentralization of the owning over the means of production spread out to those who work. Like a worker cooperative when it comes to companies. The government is designed to protect the worker and protect the workers fruits of his own labor. The government is also there to help lessen the costs to and provide for the essentials for life. The government needs to protect against corruption of the life essentials by not allowing private interests inject profit or self serving models…uphold proof of work. Yes, in a nut shell socialism is proof of work protocol.
Crony capitalism is the same as capitalism…just more advanced.
I'm getting the impression from both of you that a majority of your reading has been in the vein of Marxism.
Ultimately I think we care about many of the same things, but have fundamental disagreements on the solution. Since you have found and held bitcoin, I am optimistic that you'll both eventually realize that the government is the problem, not the market.
However, if you'd like to challenge yourselves a bit I would highly recommend reading The Road to Serfdom by F.A. Hayek and/or The Anatomy of the State by Murray Rothbard.
I have read those. I was an anarchist for many years. I think that if you challenge yourself you will find that Bitcoin was created to decentralize power and cripple the rent seeking nature of capitalism. In all actuality, the protocols the govern Bitcoin are extremely similar to socialist ideology.
Also, “the market” and capitalism are not synonymous.
I understand that based on your definition of capitalism.
Not sure how anyone can have a differing opinion on capitalism. Adam Smith put it into words and others have reiterated but it’s generally accepted how I have described it to you before.
If you have a different definition, I would love to know and any sources you can provide would be great. I have read pretty much everyone who has wrote on free markets, capitalism, the state, Marxism, socialism, communism, and everything in between.
I provided two book recommendations two messages back. If you enjoy those, I would recommend reading more Rothbard or Thomas Sowell.
I have already read them, thank you. I recommend reading and listening to Dr. Richard Wolff, research worker cooperatives, and read more about Chinas great economic awakening.
True.
Other type of capitalism is just theoretical.