Gm Nobody cares about decentralization and censorship resistance except weirdos like us To win our apps must be more fun and rewarding than traditional social media, decentralization notwithstanding

Replies (24)

My assumption is that most people today are addicted to dopamine— to the point where they feel the need to scroll “For You” feeds every hour. Nostr doesn’t reinforce that kind of behavior, which is probably why most people aren’t moving here. But at the same time, I don’t want us to build that kind of feed either. I’m not sure which problem we should be solving— because helping people break that addiction feels like a very heavy task.
Default avatar
Jacob 1 month ago
Traditional platforms as Facebook and Twitter are helping since the experiences are declining. The absense of algorithms is really a plus and atm I almost prefer nostr. My dopamin addiction stil prefer traditional platforms though
It is the other stuff where it's at. Nobody wants another twitter. Just look at truthsocial, threads or bluesky and i am sure they have thrown way more money and marketing at it than nostr can ever hope to receive.
JackTheMimic's avatar
JackTheMimic 1 month ago
What is winning in this context? Is decentralization and the inability to take down this network all the incentive you need to keep using it? Why is everyone's goal seemingly to get everyone on the planet using their thing? If you find it useful, use it. If you think other people would find it useful, tell them about it. The alternative is to be in prison with everyone else. Don't lament being free just because all the people you think are dummies are stuck in prison.
Aedifico's avatar
Aedifico 1 month ago
Working on it... subscribing to topics, not hashtags or keywords. gm image
Fun and rewarding is up against easy and addictive. Perhaps winning is creating more applications that scale the protocol with steady adoption and growth. Perhaps the nostr protocol winning looks more like Linux than TikTok.
I posted a video explaining 9 reasons why 'we shouldn’t keep money in banks.' Most comments thanked me, but there were also many comments from people who are very confident that banks won’t fail and completely trust them. I feel really discouraged.
It was a generation ago that society shifted from the centralized medium of TV to the decentralized medium of the (90s) internet. Since then, the Internet became much more centralized. It might be a generational struggle to reverse it.
It's like whatsapp vs all other similar apps. It is a few people that use something else out of principle. I have no numbers but i would assume that all the above social twitter clones counted together are not a fraction of the amount of users of actual twitter and this is how people will use it. Most people they follow are on twitter, most people following them are on twitter. So unless you have a specific niche reason to use another you go to twitter. Given the fact that all other platforms are 99% the same except for being: trump supporters (truthsocial) or elon haters (anything but twitter) or paid by The Zuck (threads) there is no reason for them to come to nostr for the twitter clone ever. Except for the exact reasons you mentioned above already. That is why i think the other stuff is something where innovation can be found with a novelty that will make nostr attractive.
The only value of social media is as a distributiom platform, which Nostr does not have the network to support. Forums and communities are the only way to go if focusing soley on social-first applications.
the axiom's avatar
the axiom 1 month ago
if no one cares then it's not going to happen anyway