GitHub Copilot is just a programmer worse than you typing over you on your own screen and asking you to review their code all day every day.

Replies (28)

Water Blower's avatar
Water Blower 2 years ago
Exactly. I watch junior developers using it and it's painful to watch.
There are times when people try to contribute my code with copilot. and i could tell you that it's worse & less optimized.
💯 once we can train one of these privately and locally, on our own code and local patterns/standards, only then will I be interested
db42's avatar
db42 2 years ago
I actually feel like it’s making me a worse programmer. It’s definitely comes in handy sometimes, but is just making me lazy so I’m shutting it off.
And that (code) is the only plausible use case of AI .. because all other use cases - text answers , translations, music , art, call center agents etc can't justify the cost of compute .. humans are still lot more intelligent and lot cheaper .. and lot easier to higher , train and fire ..
Default avatar
sergiu 2 years ago
It's crazy. It forgets to close brackets. Just like a "normal" programmer. Reminds me of the Turing test, something along the lines: Human: Who do you think is going to win? Computer: Team A. Human: why? Computer: I don't know. I just think so
Recently I turned it off and I actually feel how my code has improved, specially flow. You get in the zone much quicker. I do turn it on if I know I have to so some repetitive task
Will it stay this way or eventually get good enough to save people time?
fiatjaf's avatar fiatjaf
GitHub Copilot is just a programmer worse than you typing over you on your own screen and asking you to review their code all day every day.
View quoted note →
I used to use it for boilerplate and error handling until I recently noticed that it would occasionally mix up “ok” and “err”… Things like: v, err := someMap[key] The “i” in LLM stands for intelligence :>
Pode ajudar alguns não programadores a iniciar na programação. As IAs abrem algumas portas pra troca de áreas techs para pessoas não techs. Mas não deveria ser utilizado para programar. Profissionais ainda estão muito melhores do que IAs.
This is another interesting perspective. I was thinking that it’s just a programmer with very low salary and can work on any questions. With even super stupid questions.