Ive gone back and forth on the efficacy of BIP110(to my ability) and I've kind of decided that to me BIP110 is more of a signal of where I want Bitcoin to go than anything. It may not be perfect, but I don't think it will cause much if any harm, and I think sending the signal that Bitcoin is focusing on the money aspect is worthwhile.

There needs to be a better proposal.

What are the risks and disadvantages of BIP-110? Why the community is so divided? If it's so good as it seems why are so many smart people against it? @Giacomo Zucco and many others

Well said, and I think many feel the same.