I've lived in the world of "You can just do things" for so long that meeting people who worship credentialism shocks me back to reality. I didn't get a degree in Winemaking. So many people are pacified by a system that wants you to ask for permission to do anything. You don't need permission and you definitely don't need to pay the price of a house to learn from someone who talks about doing things for a living instead of doing them. The whole arrangement is masturbatory. For you and for the winners of a system that gets off on keeping you trapped and docile. You have all the tools and information available to go 1) find the thing you are passionate about 2) learn how to do it or find someone willing to teach you. Be curious. Keep moving.

Replies (50)

Adrian M Lopez's avatar
Adrian M Lopez 4 months ago
Alright fine. I’ll learn how to be a therapist without the fiat education system.
🫡🙌 sir. Wanted to write a bitcoin book/novel, so wrote one, does the address at the bottom of the peonie lane website get parcels to you?
John's avatar
John 4 months ago
My work constantly brags about having the best people from the best schools and I taught myself via youtube
GJM's avatar
GJM 4 months ago
I get what you are saying but it’s only one side of the coin. While it is possible to identify and practice a “craft” that you can bypass some of the so called required hoops that get you your piece of paper, many industries are built to be gated communities where the only way you can legally practice your skill and craft is via licensing based on your expensive piece of paper or credential. Lots of people are fully aware that while much of their credential experience is a joke, they can also see that it is foundational to the “privilege to practice.”
M A D E X's avatar
M A D E X 4 months ago
haha I get the same question for art you must have / did you go to art school
Absolutely that exists and of your passion got captured by credentialism that doesn't mean you shouldn't go after it. My post was about going after your dreams and not asking for permission. The other side of the coin isn't "well actually sometimes you need a degree to practice", it's being to scared to bet on yourself
Sounds like your dream career for captured by credentialism. My post is about making shit happen in your life and not asking permission with degrees as a naritive advice. Pessimism is pointless. Go win
I'm a mechanical engineer, I have a well regarded degree from a well regarded school, and most day's my jobs to quietly sit at a desk and think or debate ideas, and I love the way my want-to-be elite friends, neighbors, and coworkers look at me when I say things like: "we way overvalue the expertise of knowing and way undervalue the expertise of doing", "unless a person's from a field that involves lots of relevant experiments, and deference to experimental results, I don't care what they think; I care what surgeons, farmers, and plumbers think; I generally don't care what social scientists, philosophers, or public health people think", "for most academics and experts, their expertise is in reading the room regarding their own field, but nothing more", "like with many religious figures, there's a chicken and egg problem among many experts; while they're the most knowledgeable ones on their topics, they typically only ended up that way because they started out naive but sufficiently passionate to spend years getting credentialed, so they're clearly biased and typically seem to have an agenda", or "for the most part, an expert is just a person for whom it's socially acceptable to lazily, mindlessly outsource your thinking to and blindly follow.". They look at me like I'm a bad person, or a trader, and I suppose that in a way I am, because I want to acknowledge reality, and do what works, not what sounds nice, or brings prestige 😆
GJM's avatar
GJM 4 months ago
So what you are saying is that you should not be afraid of granting yourself permission to go after your passion? You are saying don’t let the lack of acquiring a credential in order to practice your passion stop you from finding an alternative way to gain the skills, insights and network benefits that usually come from jumping through a credential hoop. You are focusing on the personal permission side of the equation and not on the permission side given by a legal organisation that requires credentials to practice.
I'm not rich and always try to make the point of my posts about saying yes to the specific opportunities that you are most equipped to take advantage of. I also am speaking without nuance. I inherited my dad's hobby and hoped he would teach me how to do it. Once I'd committed my life savings to that idea, I learned that he didn't know what he was doing and that I was on my own. Hate if you want.
GJM's avatar
GJM 4 months ago
Hahaha, not sure if you are being facetious or genuinely agree. I pushed back a little on your post because I was personally affected by a set of credentials that mean nothing in my chosen industry. In fact what mattered most was a proof of work history. My chosen industry/passion is so loosely governed that the lowest point of entry is simply a willingness to work OR a bunch of cash to bank roll a business venture. There are however some industries adjacent to mine that we are always use that require credentials to practice. The body of work gets built AFTER the credential is attained. While I absolutely agree in principle with what you are saying in terms of getting after your passion, I think it would be a crying shame to have encouraged someone to waste X thousands of hours perfecting a craft skill set only to be denied access to the ranks of your passion at the last minute because you need to be “qualified.”
It just sounded a little AI so I didn't take the time to respond much since I wasn't sure if you were human. If you're agreeing with me why are you getting lost in the nuance. I can't make. Every Nostr post to reflect every specific situation
Adrian M Lopez's avatar
Adrian M Lopez 4 months ago
I was being completely serious! I’ve talked to a therapist who said she would’ve just gone the life coaching route rather than waste her time at school. I’ve been considering this approach for a while now because I get more satisfaction out of helping people in their lives overall rather than just massaging them. Your post felt targeted at me 🤣
GJM's avatar
GJM 4 months ago
Because nuance is where people get fucked over. Just because both you and I have had great experiences getting on with our shit and finding relative success doesn’t mean we have cracked some sort of full proof code to success or happiness. I have 3 sons and have learned by personal experience that nuance matters when helping them through their shit. I agreed with the starting point of your post but I think you needed to qualify it by describing what the barriers to entry for your winemaking passion/experience were. If you required no credentials then the barrier is lower for your chosen passion. I know you mean well but I am sticking my neck out about the nuance because without highlighting it your advice is potentially terrible. 🤷‍♂️ Anyway, we could be potentially arguing about something even more useless like which translation of the bible is the best for understanding universal blanket black and white saving truth! 🤪
GJM's avatar
GJM 4 months ago
I think you are over reacting. I hope this doesn’t stop us from having interesting conversations in the future. 🙂
GJM's avatar
GJM 4 months ago
Noted, but what I would say is that you were the one who was tempted to stop progress by calling BS on nuance, not me. Anyway, let’s leave the channel open because I have really enjoyed your Nostr contribution 😁
Default avatar
bulbrigertin 4 months ago
Worshiping credentialism is fucking assinine But respecting expertise is fucking basic It all comes down to the value of the credential.
↑