Just saying but debanking would become a hell of a lot harder if all banks ran on ecash
Login to reply
Replies (30)
Ecash haters seething rn
But they’d still be able to rug you on ecash
Mostly agree, but what I don't yet fully get is how we trust that something like a bank isn't surveiling transactions anyways. It's easy to say you're running an ecash mint.
They have to rug everyone, rather than individuals. Still not ideal, but it is an overall improvement.
bitcoiners in 2014: our thing is so cool, it will kill fractional reserve banking
bitcoiners in 2024: what if we enable banks to keep doing fractional reserve
No, they don’t have to rug everyone, the guardians/custodians just create more ecash tokens than there’s bitcoin backing it and the last one with the bag gets rugged as others can cash out
This is my understanding
In a KYCed ecash system sure, but it still offers transactional privacy.
The majority of debanking originates with transaction flagging, for example if you sent money to an exchange. Goes as far down as being flagged for using the wrong words, see e.g. EFF coverage here:
Thats why mints are auditable
even if ecash mints were aduitable, it's not going to retroactively protect anyone. even if you can see who stole the cookie from the cookie jar, the cookie's still fucking gone. nothing stops them from stealing the cookies in the first place. ecash is a regression.
Shadow banking has already accomplished a lot of that.
Why use something complex as ecash for this? They can already do this with ETF's, or start an exchange.
So you can pay bills, set up direct debits, get credit and get cash from an ATM through shadow banking?
You can run up the systemic credit, and render the Fed essentially useless. Furthermore, it can fricking crash the system. 24/7. That is shadow banking. #study
Can romanticize BTC and any crypto for that matter; but I think it was Nietsche who coined the phrase, "will to power". BTC is challenging almost every sovereign power who has every interest in devaluing their debt obligations. FX market alone is multi trillions. Good luck. Got a big challenge ahead.
Just use Monero
Auditable doesn’t mean they have to audit and the banks might not let you audit it that easily either (don’t know if that’s even possible for the users)
I’m not sure what effects one would have in terms of privacy when the mints are auditable
Make banking like it was 1870 again.
Debanking starts to sounds like a feature, a whole new decentralized banking paradigm.
Ouch
I thoight the mints have blind signatures so they wouldn't know who to steal from in the first place, right?
Good question, not sure how a bank would go about that (other than "here's our mint")
because in an ecash system, the user creates the ecash, and the mint blinly signs it.
It's a user-mint interaction, that only works if both parties play by the book.
It's not just like the provider/bank says they are using ecash, and you have to trust them.
If you don't understand or would like to know more on how it works, let me know
Ndnd
Thanks, that helps. If you have a link that explains it more I wouldn't mind taking a look
Ecash provides better tradeoffs for existing custodial systems, plain and simple... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Just saying but debanking would become a hell of a lot harder if all banks ran on ecash
View quoted note →
bankers have got too much power from the respective governments to rule like little dictators and they do enjoy it without doubt. bankers should just be service provides nothing more nothing less.
they can steal from everyone and nobody would notice until people decided to withdraw their money. they could all be doing fractional reserve right now. it's the same thing as fractional reserve banking and it's similar to an exit scam. it circumvents the 21 million coin cap.
sure thing!
Here in this article is a short explanation on how it works:
Here are some slides I made a while back, illustrating the process:
there is also a simulator, if you want to know about the more technical details:
https://numbnoot.gandlaf.com/
it doesn't display well on mobile though, so only visit the site on desktop
Stacker News
Chaumian E-Cash on Bitcoin: Banks in Cyberspace or Regulatory Capture? \ stacker news
Chaumian E-Cash on Bitcoin: Banks in Cyberspace or Regulatory Capture? Cashu is an open protocol enabling users to take advantage of Chaumian e-cas...
Ecash
Truth
Mints are not auditable. She is clueless. Fractional reserve is easily possible and individual users can be censored.