Replies (44)

Default avatar
Excommunicado 4 months ago
The only way forward is to give users ability to run their own infrastructure. Like nostr, like simplex.
fade2's avatar
fade2 4 months ago
What is the default privacy preserving steps the wallet has baked in?
Very cool but the whole “private messaging and self-custodial Bitcoin, together at last.” smells like Bs to anyone whos been on Nostr for the past couple of years.
Seems like a solution looking for a problem. What is wrong with having the Signal app and a separate wallet?
I think the concept is fine. It’s the value prop for Nostr + zaps and probably has even more of an instant user base since it rides on signal. My issue was the claim that it’s the first to combine secure messaging with bitcoin.
Signal can be switched off because it's a centralized service. There were proposals to decentralize however the devs (ie. Moxie Marlinspike) undermined this since long ago. Also Marlinespike is known for shutting down services when they are needed most. DYOR!
yeah i was trying to use both and it wasn't working. ended up just removing radar chat for now. i'll just wait till it's more mature before deciding if i should switch over.
the wallet is not very private, uses spark could argue it’s more private than venmo but low bar
Monero Dog's avatar
Monero Dog 4 months ago
That's an understatement if there ever was one. Spark logs IP addresses and can freeze user funds for any reason whatsoever. Their claims of unilateral exit are a lie.
Kudzai Kutukwa's avatar
Kudzai Kutukwa 4 months ago
Exactly that, since it needs your phone number like Signal
beta testing the software that will be used by the next generation of global communist snitch networks
Kudzai Kutukwa's avatar
Kudzai Kutukwa 4 months ago
It's definitely a step in the right direction except the part where it needs my number. Other than that, it's a decent messenger with great potential and different tradeoffs.
Kudzai Kutukwa's avatar
Kudzai Kutukwa 4 months ago
Guess they inherited that phone number part from the signal stack, or it was the easy way out than to do the Simplex way
it's sybil attack mitigation. also known as a unique identifier. but hasn't simp security been broken? the fact that the obvious solution of self custody of your secret in an asymmetric cryptographic public key infrastructure hasn't occurred to them somehow, mysteriously, even though nostr has been around for 4 years now. i just don't know how they could have never thought of that. they must be living under a rock. also, 6 months ago, i got claude to export my signal chat history, because some stupid people were using signal to bullshit me. i learned that it didn't use a proper nonce (cleartext, random prefix that is combined with the secret key) - AND it also used gnome keychain for the secret. and none of that was made visible in the interface. the nonce was literally 12 space characters. a placeholder. no actual random generation. completely broken for plaintext attacks.
Kudzai Kutukwa's avatar
Kudzai Kutukwa 4 months ago
Whoa 🤯 As for using the public/private key pair like Nostr, I think it did occur to them but the sink costs into current paradigm probably was a a huge factor resulting in it being ignored. Or they just don't care lol
see, if they didn't carefully make sure linux desktop version of signal used a proper random cryptographic nonce for the sqlite conversation database, one has to wonder if they have any crypto chops at all. if you want to verify what i'm saying, get claude or other robot to investigate your desktop signal database, with what i said, and see if it's still that. the nonce is visible, plaintext. it can detect that just by reading the file, the robots can understand binary
Kudzai Kutukwa's avatar
Kudzai Kutukwa 4 months ago
Will definitely check it out and see but in and of itself it's very concerning that this app which has become the "gold standard" of privacy has these major vulnerabilities
Asking the right question. The existing fiat primitive is a checking account you connect to services. Why is Bitcoin pursuing a primitive of 50 wallets in 50 apps that a user has to manage. Cognitive load, anyone?
JackTheMimic's avatar
JackTheMimic 4 months ago
Because everybody has absolutely forgotten the Unix philosophy.
Kudzai Kutukwa's avatar
Kudzai Kutukwa 4 months ago
I understand but that's still bad for privacy. Will this be addressed in future?
If only there was a decentralised network and social graph that used public keys instead of phone numbers!
↑