GM Some pension experience for the younger plebs thinking of starting a private pension. My wife started a private pension 25 years ago. She paid in a fixed monthly amount matched by her employer. After 25 years it matured, my wife was given the option to re-invest, but being Bitcoiners, we decided to cash out to become self sovereign. If we include the matched employer contributions, the pension has lost money. However on just my wife’s contribution, it has made, after 24% capital gains tax, about 60% gain in total. However, as inflation has caused at least 50% loss of value over 25 years, then in absolute terms it has lost money. Next, pension companies, like banks don’t like giving you your money. Despite the payout date being the 15th April, we only received the money after a lot of hassle and threats of issuing a wind up order to the company. We received the money in the bank yesterday. What seemed like a significant amount of money to my wife when she started the pension has turned into a relatively insignificant payout today. We are putting two thirds of the payout into Bitcoin and will be using the remainder to pay bills and for my wife to treat herself to a spa day or something similar. This is the reality of the fiat world.

Replies (74)

Zaikaboy's avatar
Zaikaboy 7 months ago
This is almost identical to what we've just been through unfortunately I can't touch my work pension for another couple of years. I just hope I get it.
When Barclays froze my account because they saw me buying Bitcoin, I treated the conversation as if they were about to go bankrupt. I offered to bail them out and started wind up procedure against them. They quickly opened up my account again. Unfortunately, my wife is less confrontational, so played the normal game, thus it took a lot longer and was more hassle.
GMHappy Satsurday. I converted my 401k(retirement account) same as your wife. Luckily did not have any hassles. Basically it treaded water with inflation the whole time. I thought it increased in value until I learned about bitcoin and purchasing power debasement with money printing. A penny saved became a Sat earned!🤝
Potentially for Barclays, yes, but for the Pension company no. That's not really the point tho, having a wind up ordered issued is enough to start a bank run / pension run on a company. Simply having this in place could be disastrous for a company, they will normally do anything to avoid it if at all possible.
It's very common in business. There was a famous case where somebody placed a winding up order on to the BBC. Nobody noticed. It nearly went through ending the 100 year life of the institution 😂
The company would simply pay the outstanding amount to the creditor to make it go away automatically. If it's a significant amount, it's a very common way to recover funds.
Madness. The idea of this sense of unfairness at scale is very troubling I would be so pissed off And you guys are in a small minority that understand Bitcoin and can start to make back some of those gains Pension is a scam
Ironically, if they'd paid out when they were supposed to, Bitcoin was around $83K. We are loosing more gains by putting it in at $103K
rapadu's avatar
rapadu 7 months ago
WHAT?! Gotto look into that. Thanks. Btw. Are you going to attend bitcoin beach retreat in north Wales this summer?
I haven't heard about it, just looking at it now. It's near our wedding anniversary, so the wife will have to be onboard 😂
The scandal on my fathers side of the family, was my grandfather had half his Navy pension taken away as he was medically discharged 12 days before he was due to finish his term of service. My grandfather lived with that grudge for the rest of his life.
I don't blame him for that. Outright theft has been normalised to the point where all people do is throw their hands up in exasperation and do nothing about it.
Hello™️'s avatar
Hello™️ 7 months ago
lol I’ve heard this a few times and I believe it, same with the states and social security it’s unsustainable Also the U.K. state pension legally isn’t a pension, it’s a benefit. They’re not obligated to pay you shit out of that Ponzi scheme, so even better that you’re forced to pay into it
A lot of people think your paying into your future state pension. You're not, you're paying the people that are already retired, as soon as you pay it, it's gone out again. A bit like the Bitcoin Steak n Shake are accepting for payment, as soon as they receive it, it's converted into shitty fiat.
A major mistake people make is leaving the money they pay into a pension to be managed by someone else. For those Bitcoiners in the UK who already have money in a pension the best option is to use it to buy actual Bitcoin (and self-custody it). At least that way your pension is held in the best-performing asset. At retirement age, whether to drawdown all in a single lump-sum or over time as an income would depend on personal circumstances and preferences. One major advantage of pensions currently is that gains are free from capital gains tax (at least for now, I would not be surprised if the gov changed that). For this reason I imagine drawing down as needed would be the better option rather than taking it all as a lump sum, incurring income tax, then having capital gains due on any Bitcoin you bought with it. Just let the Bitcoin appreciate without capital gains, then take out whatever each year, maximising your annual personal allowance and possibly avoiding higher income tax brackets. As far as paying more into a pension post-orange-pilling, as you say, stacking self-sovereign sats seems like a better option. However, this is often complicated slightly by the fact you'd typically lose out on the employer contribution if you don't make contributions of your own.
Agreed, except the “free of CGT”, the payout was taxed at source at 24% CGT, that was a significant reason the pension didn’t perform. Tax free pensions, refer to the input, not the output tax. Be very careful of this, Pensions are NOT tax free.
In the UK at least you may get tax reductions for paying in but, as you say, when drawing down your pension it is all subject to income tax (except the 25% tax-free lump sum, up to a limit of £268,275). Gains in most pensions are free from CGT though: > The disposal of an investment held for the purposes of a registered pension scheme is not a chargeable gain. It is therefore exempt from capital gains tax. There are some exemptions for atypical situations, such as overseas pensions schemes, which may explain having to pay CGT.
I'm not going to declare the actual numbers, but this is the actual reality. My wife contributed £0.45p The employer contributed £0.45p At maturity, after 25 years, the pension pot was £1 After tax, we received £0.76p The amount was not even close to £268,275.
Pension pot: £1 25% tax-free lump sum: £0.25 Higher income tax of 40% on remaining £0.75: £0.30 Pension pot after income tax: £0.25 + £0.75 - £0.30 = £0.70 Effective tax rate: 30% This would be reduced a bit if taking into account personal allowance. For example if the pension pot was £100k and the personal allowance £12,500 the effective tax rate would be 25%.
Jon's avatar
Jon 7 months ago
I have a sipp but it's invested entirely in #mstr. I think this is the best option. I'm either going to be broke or very rich. I haven't contributed any further money since about 3 years ago when I went self employed.
Yes, the pension options emerging now are much greater than 25 years ago. For me the main purpose of a pension is to stop you spending your money too quickly. As Bitcoiners, we are mostly disciplined to do this.
Jon's avatar
Jon 7 months ago
I've got 12 years until I can take the pension. If mstr continues it'll be the biggest pension in the world 😂
Straight out of Mandibles, when the professor finally received his severance from the university after delays of several years
Lululuna's avatar
Lululuna 7 months ago
In Australia we are able to claim our superannuation funds that have been automatically deducted from our Fiat pay checks each week. We transfer our balance to a SELF MANAGED SUPER FUND, then purchase BTC. The process is still easy and fast. Great post sharing the reality and new mindset in regards to savings plans.
Stumbled across this interesting thread reg pensions in the UK. I'm 45, I suspect I'll never see a state pension. If I do, I'd have to work beyond 70. And there are women in the UK campaigning for the right to retire at 60. So they expect me to work for the next 25+ years to pay them to sit on their arses when I'll likely never be afforded the same degenerate luxury. So many leaches. Instead, I'll keep doing what I'm doing.
mike's avatar mike
GM Some pension experience for the younger plebs thinking of starting a private pension. My wife started a private pension 25 years ago. She paid in a fixed monthly amount matched by her employer. After 25 years it matured, my wife was given the option to re-invest, but being Bitcoiners, we decided to cash out to become self sovereign. If we include the matched employer contributions, the pension has lost money. However on just my wife’s contribution, it has made, after 24% capital gains tax, about 60% gain in total. However, as inflation has caused at least 50% loss of value over 25 years, then in absolute terms it has lost money. Next, pension companies, like banks don’t like giving you your money. Despite the payout date being the 15th April, we only received the money after a lot of hassle and threats of issuing a wind up order to the company. We received the money in the bank yesterday. What seemed like a significant amount of money to my wife when she started the pension has turned into a relatively insignificant payout today. We are putting two thirds of the payout into Bitcoin and will be using the remainder to pay bills and for my wife to treat herself to a spa day or something similar. This is the reality of the fiat world.
View quoted note →
For me this experience has highlighted how important it is to not let any third party have any control of your money or life.
Ares's avatar
Ares 7 months ago
GM Some pension experience for the younger plebs thinking of starting a private pension. My wife started a private pension 25 years ago. She paid in a fixed monthly amount matched by her employer. After 25 years it matured, my wife was given the option to re-invest, but being Bitcoiners, we decided to cash out to become self sovereign. If we include the matched employer contributions, the pension has lost money. However on just my wife’s contribution, it has made, after 24% capital gains tax, about 60% gain in total. However, as inflation has caused at least 50% loss of value over 25 years, then in absolute terms it has lost money. Next, pension companies, like banks don’t like giving you your money. Despite the payout date being the 15th April, we only received the money after a lot of hassle and threats of issuing a wind up order to the company. We received the money in the bank yesterday. What seemed like a significant amount of money to my wife when she started the pension has turned into a relatively insignificant payout today. We are putting two thirds of the payout into Bitcoin and will be using the remainder to pay bills and for my wife to treat herself to a spa day or something similar. This is the reality of the fiat world.
Here in Luxembourg you have no choice but to subscribe to what is called CCSS, which translate to Social Security Community Center. It can take up to 30% of your salary -- Tax are not paid yet. It serve as your health and pension funds. I'm subscribing knowing my pension will be worthless, I'm 35.
Yeah, it’s the fiat capital of Europe. Real Estate is inflated like nowhere else. Don’t fall for these numbers though, people are struggling even in the richer country. Especially the young.
If a company owes you £750 or more you can start the wind up procedure. I know a few who have used this. It gets messy when the company in question actually opts for bankruptcy. That’s when you’re likely to lose your money or only recoup a fraction.
Not always - some stay afloat and this approach is a legal kick up the arse to get them to pay up. And once you’ve tied your creditor status within a legal framework you’re prioritised if they do go bankrupt. Somewhat unrelated but I once officially became a creditor when an online company folded just after I ordered an item from them - was very interesting to be involved in the wind up process.