Speaking about free speech, I’ve been noticing something on YouTube that bothers me a lot. Why are the words rape and suicide being censored so hard? Because they’re “triggering”? Some things should be triggering. A rape survivor should be able to talk about what happened to them without sugar coating it or saying “r-worded” in its’ place. She wasn’t “r-worded”, she was raped and has every right to talk about it and use the word that defines her experience. Same thing with people who have lost loved ones to suicide…they aren’t allowed to talk about what happened without using the termed “unalived” him/herself. They aren’t protecting anyone by censoring these words, they’re shaming the victims by saying their experience is something that cannot be expressed publicly.

Replies (67)

Default avatar
Alex 10 months ago
Expect nothing from YouTube, their ai even censors the comments in real time
Yes and I’m saying why are the platforms censoring those particular words and who do they think they’re protecting? To me it seems like censoring those words only protects to perpetrators
I think other people have said it, but it's pretty much to get around censorship and to avoid being demonetized. It's extremely stupid, but that's life on a centralized platform, I guess.
Advertisers consider themselves as sponsors of the videos their ads play with. They worry that people will associate their product with something negative if their ads are played alongside that negative thing.
Not a new trend that's confined only to social media. Governments don't want their docile tax-playing sheep to be inspired to unalive themselves because that would reduce taxes they received. Note that the MASH TV series theme song had its lyrics completely removed ie instrumental only. Not the movie it was based on though :
Juls's avatar
Juls 10 months ago
Sadly, the list of words that can demonetize content on centralized social media will only continue to grow... which is absolutely ridiculous, especially in cases like the ones you've presented. However from what I know, YT is one of the worst.
Not a new trend that's confined only to social media. Governments don't want their docile tax-playing sheep to be inspired to unalive themselves because that would reduce taxes they received. Note that the MASH TV series theme song had its lyrics completely removed ie instrumental only. Not the movie it was based on though :
Yeah it's dumb. Maybe nostr and v4v fixes this, but I'm afraid most people have grown too used to getting things for "free". YouTube is not interested in improving the experience of users because the users aren't their customers, they are their product that they sell to advertisers. They only want to increase engagement so people watch more videos and more ads.
I think that in a sense it's taking the power from those words. If we don't say them, we "forget" about them, then they can be re-vamped in to something less than 🤷‍♀️. I'm not great at putting my thoughts in to words about this, maybe you can get the jist of what I'm trying to say...
Yes that is pretty messed up. I feel like it got worse with TikTok when 'unaliving' became a replacement for death. Censorship does something interesting to language. When there is a will there is a way. Notice the title of the short 😅
Lucas M's avatar
Lucas M 10 months ago
It's like they're trying to convince people that rape and suicide don't exist. Corporate control needs to end.
TheLegendaryMan's avatar
TheLegendaryMan 10 months ago
They are protecting the offenders. Not the victims. As more high profile cases become aware by the public these censorship tools become essential for damage control. A vile practice that deserves a class action lawsuit against youtube for violating freedom of speech.
Society is so concerned with "protecting" that they forgot the consequences of endless protection from hard truths: A complete inability to deal with hardship and a total lack of perseverance and grit.
Censoring the word "suicide" was originally the discussion topic that Bluesky staff picked as an excuse to block me from their main accounts and start promoting more targeted harassment against me on there (long before they banned me) They openly said they would censor anyone that mentioned suicide on Bluesky in any context, and I kept replying in the thread where they announced the policy change, standing up for suicidal people who need to talk to others. This was in the past few years where I've been worrying about Digit every day, so this blatant targeting and ostracization of suicidal people makes me beyond angry A staff member in the thread called pfrazee blocked me and it snowballed from there I ended up changing my username to "blocked by pfrazee" so anyone asking about it would get a reminder of the day this all started and what topic was being discussed Sadly #nostr is only like 10% better than Bluesky and even the npub I'm replying to has joined in with the targeted harassment against me here on nostr by muting me